LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost a replyNext message

City:Evanston, IL USA WA
Personal Data:Male, born: July 17 1944
Membership20years 96days ago.
Last Login13years 144days ago.
Last Move13years 183days ago.
Bombadil is currently Offline!Send a mail to Bombadil


Message header
Area/Game:Blue Max
Topic:Other
Subject:Re: Please make it stop
Posted by: Bombadil - 18years 306days ago.
Message text
Lord_Biclopse wrote:
Tornade wrote:
Galinette wrote:
I agree with all these good ideas to reduce the risks to find blocked games by ignorant or malevolent players.

As we play the roles of Knights of the sky that are supposed to have a certain code of honnour, why wouldn't we create a kind of "Honnour level" calculated by the computer (if technically possible, of course...) for each of the players.
We would have to determinate what is Honnour according to some parameters: period of game since the subscription to "youplay.it, absence of automove for a certain period, etc...

Honnour could be represented for example by a symbol from 1 star (or medal, etc...) for the "less" respectful to 4 stars for the old players that have always respected the other players or the ones that rarely play in automove.

That wouldn't prevent a "bad" player from starting new games, but everybody would quickly know the reputation and the fairplay of everyone.
Every player would indeed appear with his name and his Honnour level. That would encourage all of us to improve our behaviour and would fit with the "Chevaliers du ciel" spirit !

A player ranked "1 star" for example could only join certain games with certain conditions and limits (4 gamers games maximum for example, or the impossibility to join the league games, etc...). And the 4 stars players would have no restrictions at all.

In fact, I am very enthusiastic by this philosophy based on Honnour, respect and fair-play, even if I don't know how long and how difficult it is to be tecnically elaborated. And maybe having a more controlled and limited site isn't the philosophy expected by its creators...

Any comments or suggestions about all this?

Galinette, the utopian pilot


i see it as a good concept...but i wonder about the mechanics of determining the ratings

how would we determine how a player is rated...
not by how many games he plays...i have played against some pretty sleazy players with fairly high numbers of games played...length on the site...again the same problem creeps up...the opinion of other players...it would be difficult to pole everyone reliably and what would stop a good old boys network from happening...i am sure there are other difficulties that could be associated with such a system...but i for one would completely support it if someone could insure its fairness

once again i have to point to the fact that newbies will not be anxious to remain in the site if they are not being allowed to play and i think it is important to make them feel welcome as fast as possible for the site to grow

MJC


I think Galinette’s idea of an honour system is an excellent one, though potentially quite complicated. And I agree with Tornade – I don’t think there should be anything to stop newbies launching into the game with huge enthusiasm (as I did, back when I was unemployed and had lots of time). So here is my suggestion:

A four star honour system: Every player (newbies included) starts off with 4 stars. The more automoves the user takes, the more his stars drop. A set length of period without an automove gains you a star.

In the game creation screen the creator of the game can stipulate the level of honour the players of the game must have (1 or more star, 2 or more, 3 or more or 4). Players who don’t have the required numbers of stars can’t join the game. And of course if you only have 2 stars, then you can’t create a 3 star game.

Players who often experience periods of automoving could find themselves only playing other automovers. Players who don’t automove have the pleasure of playing games without an automover.

A further idea – players who donate to the site could be given a maximum of 5 stars (though there shouldn’t be an option to create a 5 star, paid-members only game). This would give the more generous players the flexibility to occasionally lapse into automove due to unexpected life commitments (as I myself have done once or twice, with computer problems etc).

This might still sound very complicated, but I think it could be made workable!

Just my thoughts anyway. Oh, and I have had more than 250 games on the go before! It is hard work, and I didn’t seem to win many.

Lord Biclopse


I like Lord B's "Star System". I am by NO MEANS a programer/webmaster, but I do think it might be awkward to implement by the good folks at YPI.

Bombadil

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

18years 307days moonglum01 [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days flying_neko Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days gugliandalf Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days SkunkGuru Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
 18years 307days pokerguy Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 306days FourthApache Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
 18years 287days flying_neko Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days Rico71 Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 306days ksnake Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days Phil Hall Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days Capt-Tuttle Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days Tornade Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days moonglum01 Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
18years 307days Galinette Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
 18years 306days Tornade Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
 18years 306days Lord_Biclopse Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 306days Bombadil Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 306days scotireb Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 306days ksnake Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 305days FourthApache Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 306days ksnake Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 305days FourthApache Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 306days Lord_Biclopse Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
 18years 305days FourthApache Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days Galinette Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days Regis Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days Galinette Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days Lord_Biclopse Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 305days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
    18years 305days Lord_Biclopse Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
    18years 304days Galinette Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days Tornade Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 305days ksnake Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
    18years 305days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
     18years 305days warrax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
      18years 305days scotireb Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
      18years 304days ksnake Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
       18years 304days pokerguy Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
       18years 304days warrax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
        18years 304days Bombadil Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
        18years 304days ksnake Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
         18years 304days warrax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
         18years 304days Bombadil Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
          18years 304days flying_neko Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
          18years 304days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
          18years 303days Tornade Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
  18years 305days BlackSheep Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
   18years 286days TrevorWigwam Re: [BM][OT] Please make it stop
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

18years 287days BazJP [BM][HUMOUR] Guns jammed up your pipe!
18years 286days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][HUMOUR] Guns jammed up your pipe!
 18years 286days TrevorWigwam Re: [BM][HUMOUR] Guns jammed up your pipe!
 18years 286days BazJP Re: [BM][HUMOUR] Guns jammed up your pipe!
 18years 286days ksnake Re: [BM][HUMOUR] Guns jammed up your pipe!
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

18years 289days Templars [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
18years 289days imdog Re: [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
18years 289days Just4Fun Re: [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
18years 288days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
18years 288days rolive1 Re: [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
 18years 288days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
18years 286days Lord Locquax Re: [BM][TOUR] Squad cup
Page generated in: 25 milliseconds.