LOGIN
User Name
Password
Remember me


Register...Forgot password?
Main menu
Leagues
Gonzaga
Blue Max
Cartagena
Wooden Ships...
King Me!
VampiRing
Forum Message
Previous messagePost on the new forumNext message

Membership22years 117days ago.
Last Login4years 253days ago.
Last Move4years 237days ago.
BlueDragon is currently Offline!Send a mail to BlueDragon


Message header
Area/Game:Blue Max
Topic:General
Subject:Re: BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
Posted by: BlueDragon - 16years 9days ago.
Message text
markrendl wrote:
TXWard wrote:
FENRIS wrote:
My only critique would be "faction loyalty".
As Templars pointed out early on (and many of us followed suit once we had our bearings on how things were being worked out) I would prefer to see less "trench-hopping". Would it be possible to commit (lock-in) a player I.D. to a particular side after his 1st plane selection, perhaps by posting a list?

I have trouble following the logic here. What's the benefit of having "phantom" accounts set up to play the opposite side of the campaign instead of allowing the same username to do it?

I'd rather see a limit to the number of pilots a player can use so as to make their lives that much more valuable. Even then, how do you prevent the "phantoms" from circumventing it?


I like being able to fly both sides and would be opposed to restrictions on that.

Restricting the number of pilots one could use would only punish those players who are the most active in the campaign, as those random one shot kills do add up rather quickly when you play a lot of games.

Thus, I'd prefer to leave things as is, as far as player participation options go.

OTOH, if we were to set up a squadron campaign, I'd have no problems with flying in the same squadron on the same side for the duration of the war as a more historical alternative to an open campaign. I think there'd perhaps be a fair number of logistical challenges to organizing and running such though.

markrendl


I agree that playing one-side-only can be nice, and it might add some more competition between Allied and Germans.
However, *enforcing* it as a restriction has quite a few disadvantages:
1) Some (many?) players actually enjoy the freedom of playing both sides, and not being stuck with flying only some type of planes.
2) While the campaign software can easily track who is assigned to which side, what happens if a players joins the wrong side? While people committed to the campaign can probably make a mistake only once in a while (or never), casual players would probably join both sides. Should we then declare "void" those games where someone switched side?
Games obviously cannot be canceled by the software and I think it's not possible to post a message in a game you are not playing..so I would not even be able to warn people that they are playing a non-valid game.
3) As noted, people with 2+ accounts can play both sides (this is actually "an advantage" if you consider that it solves (partially) problem 1).

I think that playing one side can be nice, and I would encourage people (now that we've played both sides) to play the next campaign using one-side.
However, it's probably better to leave it as a *choice* instead of forcing it, for the reasons stated above.

On the other hand, if we play a Squadron Campaign (and that is what I'd like to do next), I'd agree with enforcing a one-side only policy. A Squadron Campaign will probably need passworded games and people voluntarily joining the campaign so point 2) would probably solve by itself.

Back to the messages list
Messages thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

16years 13days BlueDragon [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days dcr66 Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 12days wetty11 Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days markrendl Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days TXWard Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days FENRIS Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days TXWard Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
 16years 13days markrendl Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
 16years 9days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
 16years 12days FENRIS Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 9days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days Mad_Bomber Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 9days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 13days TXWard Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 10days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 12days wetty11 Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 9days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
 16years 9days wetty11 Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 12days BlackSheep Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 12days GraysGhost Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 12days FENRIS Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
 16years 9days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
  16years 9days GraysGhost Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 10days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
 16years 9days BlackSheep Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 10days BlueDragon Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 5days Tombster Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
16years 4days Zamax Re: [BM] BM 2010 WWI Campaign - Armistice! Germans Won!
Next thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

16years 3days rainbow [IDEAS] Play games by Game!
16years 3days ksnake Re: [IDEAS] Play games by Game!
 16years 3days rainbow Re: [IDEAS] Play games by Game!
  16years 3days dcr66 Re: [IDEAS] Play games by Game!
   16years 3days ksnake Re: [IDEAS] Play games by Game!
Previous thread
Posting elapsed timePosted bySubject

16years 44days Ray_Collishaw [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
16years 43days Mad_Bomber Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
 16years 42days imdog Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
  16years 29days Ray_Collishaw Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
   16years 21days gugliandalf Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
    16years 15days imdog Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
     16years 12days rainbow Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
     16years 7days brewk001 Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
      16years 7days imdog Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
       16years 5days brewk001 Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
     16years 12days rainbow Re: [GZ][BUG] Multiple leagues jammed.
Page generated in: 19.33594 milliseconds.