cheepicus wrote:
I'll put this in HUMOUR since it might be too much of a joke.
So I got a little bored and I thought I would rank the planes from best to worst. It's a hopeless task, of course as some planes will be better in some situations than others. Still, it's fun and has helped me consider the strengths and weaknesses of the planes. I've tried to avoid ranking on which planes are fun.
What do you think?
** 1. Sopwith Snipe 2. SS D III/IV These first two are not surprising. ** 3. Bristol F.2B 4. Fokker D VII 5. Albatros D Va 6. SE 5a These are I think the "good" planes. The D.VII is a deadly plane but has a serious fuel problem so I think the F.2B beats it. But maybe the F2B belongs down 1-3 slots. ** 7. Nieuport 28 8. Pfalz D IIIa 9. Halberstadt CL IIa 10. SPAD XIII 11. Pfalz D XII This is the average group. The ranking here is a little hard to pin down. The Pfalz is the only "dancer" here; IMHO the rest of the dancers all have problems that keep them in a lower group. If the rules change to make stability C useful the Camel and Dr.I will shoot up into this group probably! ** 12. Albatros D III 13. Sopwith Triplane 14. Fokker Dr I 15. Sopwith Camel The Sopwith Triplane can do better, but is fragile so I place it down here. The Albatros might be better than this, and the Camel and Dr.I are too unstable and slow. ** 16. Spad VII 17. Nieuport 17 / SS D I Planes that make you want to turn around and exit the map. The Spad VII isn't horrible I suppose, but there aren't many scenarios with them.
BM is one of the few games where there isn't some sort of point value for units. Seems to me there have been enough games played here that we could come up with a point ranking system, or perhaps two - one for 1 on 1 and one for group combat.
If we all agree that the Snipe is 'the best' plane, we can give that a total of, say, 100 points. The SS DI / Nieuport are clearly the weakest in every respect - so they go to the end. In my opinion it would take about 5 SS D.I's to have a 50/50 shot at taking down a Snipe - so lets give them a value of 20 points.
From there it seems like it's simply a matter of rating each plane between these two ends. Just off the top of my head I think a Snipe is an even match for 3ish Albatros D IIIa - so, I'd give the D IIIa 33 points, but I'd also say it's substantially better than a N17 because of the 2 guns and the 180 flip... humm so perhaps I'd move that up a few points - more like 40 points.
Anyways, I'm a big picture guy. I'm sure some detail person could come up with a formula factoring in # of guns, turning, speed, fuel, durability and stability that would be more of an exact calculation.
100 points - Snipe 40 points - Pfalz DIIIa 20 points - Nieuport 17 / SS DI
a starting point |